On 19 April 1995, members from the church's Dorcas Society and the Pilgrim Service League voted to unite into one organization, Pilgrim Women's Fellowship.
The purpose of the organization is to unite the women of the parish and community in a program of fellowship, worship, education and service and to support the programs of Pilgrim Congregational Church as it serves the cause of Christ in the community and throughout the world.
Regular meetings are held the 3rd Wednesday of each month from September through May. There is a light lunch, a short business meeting and a program, which might be entertaining, inspirational or educational.
Through fund raising efforts the Pilgrim Women's Fellowship is able to support many benevolences.